Secret Never Die - Community Writing Contest - August Winner

"The Rules"

"Teach me a game."

For several seconds I wondered whether I had misunderstood him. It was not how I expected the interview to begin. I had prepared my portfolio with my best designs and the major projects I had led for big names in the industry. Before I learned why I had been summoned, what firm Adrian represented, or what plans he had for me, Adrian repeated himself with the patience of someone who had nowhere else to be.

"Teach me a game."

I assumed he meant one invented on the spot, devised for the sole purpose of entertaining this potential client. I had spent my career being hired to fix what other people had already built. Not once had I been asked to teach a game as a way of proving whether I still deserved the architect's ring I'd worn since university.

I suggested guessing games and Adrian didn't reject them. He simply waited. The silence lasted just long enough for me to begin wondering why the suggestion suddenly felt inadequate. I withdrew it before he had spoken a single word.

The silence stretched long enough that I started looking for somewhere else to put my eyes. A bay window looked out over the city, already dark. Office lights were going out floor by floor as people below finished for the night. A wooden desk positioned exactly at the room's mathematical center divided it perfectly in half. On it rested a sharpened pencil, several blank sheets of paper, and a cracked leather notebook positioned neatly beside Adrian's right hand. The door had locked behind me with the soft certainty of a mechanism designed not to be questioned. Somewhere below, a phone rang twice and stopped. No one answered it.

Adrian hadn't moved through any of it. He held himself the way old portraits hold their subjects — not rigid, exactly, but composed with the kind of formality that gets trained into a body before it's old enough to question it. A ring on his right hand had worn smooth at the crest, the metal gone soft the way old coins do.

Next to that kind of stillness I felt suddenly, absurdly underdressed — I'd worn the tie my daughter picked out that morning, the ugly blue one, because she'd asked and I never said no to her about anything that small.

Without another word, Adrian opened the notebook. The page remained blank. I waited for him to write. He didn't. The silence became strangely uncomfortable.

After some minutes I admitted I couldn't invent one.

"I did not ask you to." The correction was gentle enough that it hardly felt like one. I opened my mouth to explain myself, then stopped. He hadn't asked me to invent a game. He'd asked me to teach him one — and teaching, unlike inventing, needed something to already exist. I always found it easier to improve an existing design than to imagine one from nothing.

Chess was my first try. Adrian observed that every possible move already existed before the players ever touched the board, then asked what remained to discover besides execution. Poker lasted only a little longer. He wondered whether deception belonged to the game itself or merely to those who played it.

I suggested cards, dice, word games, even Monopoly. One after another they collapsed beneath questions that seemed almost childish until I tried to answer them. Without another word, Adrian opened the notebook. I heard his pen scratch across the paper. His hand moved without hesitation, like someone who had addressed thousands of letters. The sound lasted barely a second.

"You're not interested in the games," I said.

Adrian blinked rapidly but didn't answer. If the games weren't what interested him, then I'd been looking in the wrong place. I reached for the pencil. Every design begins with rules. The thought arrived so naturally. I wrote the first sentence almost absentmindedly.

Everyone can play. The words looked obvious once they were on the page. I considered adding qualifications—an age, a number of players, perhaps some requirement for equipment—but crossed each idea out before finishing the sentence. Every exception seemed to weaken the rule instead of strengthening it.

Adrian watched without interrupting. Only after a moment did he speak a single word.

"Why?"

"Because games are for people."

I frowned.

"No... Games are voluntary. Whether someone plays should be their decision."

I heard Adrian's pen scratch across the paper. When I looked back at my own page, another sentence had already followed the first.

One winner. I hesitated longer before writing it. There were excellent games without winners. Others rewarded everyone who participated. Cooperative games had their own appeal. Yet the more I examined them, the more I realized they all avoided the same thing: a final decision. Someone eventually had to decide, and choosing isn't a vote to be shared or a verdict to be negotiated.

I set the pencil down for a moment. I'd felt the same old tremor in my hands. Committing to a line always did this to me. Like the feeling of standing over blueprints the moment before a client signed off on something that couldn't be undone. I picked the pencil back up. Adrian wrote something again in his notebook.

The next rule took shape more slowly.

No score. That one occupied me for several minutes. I found myself thinking in terms of races, tournaments, ladders. They all measured progress instead of resolution. A race has checkpoints. A ladder has rungs. Every version rewarded consistency when what interested me was commitment. By the time I finished mapping this rule, I understood that I had been trying to disguise points under different names — the way a firm calls the next rung a promotion, so no one asks how many rungs are left, or whether the ladder ends at all.

One decision should outweigh every decision before it, I said to myself. Adrian smiled, like he'd just read my mind.

The next two rules appeared almost together.

Chance may exist. Skill may exist. For the first time, they resisted one another. Too much chance made skill irrelevant. Too much skill made chance unnecessary. I spent several minutes balancing one against the other, adding a sentence, erasing it, replacing it with another that felt only slightly less wrong. A game without an audience wouldn't need this rule at all. The game demanded judgment even if it refused to reward mastery.

The only thing left on my page was a handful of rules that no longer resembled any game I had ever played. I stared at them for a long time before another thought quietly surfaced.

"I know a game that fits."

For the first time since the interview had begun, Adrian leaned forward: "Teach me."

"It isn't mine. It came from Russia." * * * Russian roulette had never struck me as a particularly elegant game. It survived because people remembered it, not because anyone admired its design. Strip away the revolver, the stories and its reputation, and little remained beyond a sequence of increasingly desperate decisions. Until that night, I had never questioned whether that was enough.

I wrote its name at the top of a clean sheet and, before allowing myself to change anything, returned to the rules I had spent the evening uncovering. By that point, the windows in the room had stopped looking out onto the city and started reflecting the room back at us. The air had cooled without me noticing when.

Everyone can play. That rule survived the easiest. The game never cared who chose to enter it.

One winner. That survived as well. Whatever else the game allowed, only one participant could ultimately claim victory, though the word itself felt slightly uncomfortable.

No score. Nothing earned beforehand carried any weight once the game truly began. Every decision stood on its own, judged only after it had been made.

Chance may exist. Uncertainty wasn't an imperfection of the design. It was one of its foundations.

Skill may exist. This one proved more difficult. Skill could never overcome uncertainty, but it shaped every decision leading toward commitment. The decision to enter. The decision to continue. The decision not to turn away. The rule hadn't moved. It still asked for judgment, not mastery.

To my surprise, Russian roulette passed every test I had devised. That should have ended the exercise.

I looked at my scribbling. The page had become almost architectural: circles, notes scratched into the margins, then immediately underlined. Arrows traced the order of decisions. Footnotes crowded the margins where I had tried to explain why one choice inevitably produced the next. Satisfied that I could finally teach the game instead of merely describing it, I turned the paper toward Adrian.

Adrian still hadn't looked at a single page. His attention had never drifted from the person doing the thinking.

"Simplify it."

I looked back at the page. For nearly an hour I had been replacing objects with ideas, convinced I was making the game easier to explain. Only then did I realize I had been conducting a different exercise entirely. What remained wasn't the revolver. It wasn't the cylinder or the cartridge. It was a handful of ideas that refused to disappear.

Agreement preceded chance. Chance demanded commitment. Commitment invited consequence. Remove any one of them and the sequence collapsed. That answer pleased me far more than I expected. For half a second the words stopped sounding like a rule and sounded instead like an itinerary. I set the thought aside — an architect's habit, seeing structure in things that didn't ask for one — and slid the page across the table.

Adrian didn't lower his eyes.

"Are you finished?" For the first time since the interview had begun, I nodded.

His pen moved to double underline something. Adrian turned the notebook and pushed it slightly toward me without hiding it. His handwriting reminded me of my grandfather's.

His notebook was disappointingly ordinary. I expected rules arranged more elegantly than my own, perhaps a sequence I had overlooked or a solution I had been too close to recognize. Instead, I found only a few sentences, and they had nothing to do with Russian roulette.

Prefers refinement over replacement.

Corrects himself without prompting.

Redefines the problem when the first solution fails. Discards constraints before they take root.

Finds structure before seeking elegance.

The last one almost made me laugh. I had spent years arguing with clients who believed elegance came first. They admired clean lines, open spaces and striking façades, while I searched for columns, foundations and load-bearing walls. Beauty interested me only after I trusted the structure beneath it. I had never considered that habit remarkable. Adrian apparently did.

Adrian had ignored every rule I wrote on my own pages and recorded only the thinking that survived after those rules changed. I looked up from the notebook for the first time since Adrian had placed it before me.

"You knew about Russian roulette?"

His expression didn't change. "I have watched Russian officers play it before your grandfather was born."

The answer lingered somewhere behind me while my eyes drifted back to the page. I had reached what I believed was the end of Adrian's observations, yet at the bottom of the page, two simple words caught my eye.

Potential childe.

When I finally raised my eyes, Adrian was already reaching for the notebook. He closed it with the same deliberate care he had shown every time he finished writing.

"You have been writing the rules of my game all evening," Adrian said. "An ancient one, unlike anything you have played before. You may learn to play it, provided you are given time enough to. It is the players who never stop surprising you."

Adrian stood up. My portfolio remained untouched on the table. He took the notebook and walked toward the door. The lock released with a quiet click, and for the first time all evening, the room felt exactly as warm as it should have.

And as I watched him leave, I thought, uselessly, of the tie folded at my collar, and of who would notice, tomorrow, that I hadn't come home to take it off. I couldn't decide whether I had just passed the strangest interview of my career... or failed it.

I understood, a moment too late. It had never been mine to choose.

The World of Darkness Discord

Talk to other community members, discuss the latest products and find your new chronicle.

Join the Community
Stay up to date

WHITE WOLF NEWSLETTER

Sign up to get latest news from World of Darkness!

订阅即表明您同意接收 Paradox Interactive 的资讯和特惠信息。